On watchIndependent · Reader funded · No paywall
Local · 00:20

What to do when a contractor will not provide a W 9

By @taxseasonnotes

Start with the direct answer

When a contractor refuses or fails to give you a completed Form W-9, you cannot simply ignore the problem. The IRS requires you to have a valid taxpayer identification number (TIN) and legal name before you file a Form 1099-NEC or 1099-MISC for that payee. Without the W-9, you risk backup withholding obligations and penalties for incorrect or missing information returns. Your first step is to ask again, in writing, and explain the legal requirement. If the contractor still does not comply, you must begin backup withholding at 24% on all reportable payments and continue until they provide the correct TIN. You also report the payments on a 1099 using the name and TIN you have on file, even if you suspect it is wrong. The IRS will send a CP2100 or CP2100A notice if the name and TIN do not match its records, and you will need to follow up with the contractor or begin backup withholding.

Why contractors resist giving a W-9

Some independent contractors worry that providing their Social Security number or EIN will lead to more paperwork or expose them to audits. Others simply do not understand that the W-9 is a standard IRS form that protects both parties. A few may be trying to hide income from the IRS, but most are just unfamiliar with the rules. Your job as the payer is to explain clearly that the law requires you to have their correct taxpayer identification number before you can process payments for the year and issue a 1099. You can offer to send them a blank W-9 by email or mail, or point them to the IRS website where they can download it.

How to request the W-9 formally

Send a written request by certified mail or email with a read receipt. Include the form itself or a link to it, and state that you need it completed, signed, and returned within a reasonable deadline, typically 10 to 15 business days. Explain that without it, you will be required by law to deduct backup withholding from all payments. Keep a copy of the request and any responses. This paper trail protects you if the IRS later questions why you did not have a valid TIN on file. Some businesses include a W-9 request as part of the initial contract or onboarding packet, so the contractor agrees to provide it before any work begins.

Backup withholding: what it is and how it works

Backup withholding is a 24% tax the payer must deduct from reportable payments such as fees, commissions, and other compensation paid to an independent contractor. The IRS requires it when a payee fails to provide a correct TIN or when the IRS notifies you that the TIN furnished is incorrect. You must begin backup withholding on the first payment made after the contractor refuses to provide a W-9, and continue on all subsequent payments until the contractor supplies a valid TIN. You report the withheld amount on Form 945, which you file separately from your other payroll tax returns. The contractor receives a credit for the amount withheld when they file their personal tax return.

The importance of name and TIN matching

When you file a 1099, the IRS runs the name and TIN you report against its database. If they do not match, you receive a CP2100 or CP2100A notice listing the mismatches. You then have a limited time, usually 30 days, to either correct the information or begin backup withholding. This process is called TIN matching for 1099s, and it is one of the most common compliance pitfalls for businesses that pay independent contractors. Getting the legal name exactly right matters: a sole proprietor may use a business name on invoices, but the W-9 must show their individual name as it appears on their Social Security card. A corporation or LLC uses the exact name registered with the IRS. The TIN must match that name.

Checking taxpayer identification details before filing

A practical way to avoid headaches at year-end is to verify the contractor’s name and TIN before you process the first payment. You can do this through the IRS TIN matching program, which is free and available online to authorized payers. You submit the name and TIN you have, and the IRS tells you whether they match. This step is called checking taxpayer identification details, and it catches errors early. If the IRS says there is a mismatch, you ask the contractor for a corrected W-9 before you pay them. If they do not provide one, you begin backup withholding from the start. This saves you from having to go back and correct multiple 1099s later.

What to do if the contractor provides an incorrect W-9

Sometimes a contractor gives you a W-9 but the name or TIN is wrong. You might notice a typo, or the IRS may send you a mismatch notice. In either case, you must ask the contractor to submit a corrected W-9. You cannot simply change the name or number on your records yourself. The IRS expects you to rely on the information the contractor provides under penalties of perjury. If the contractor refuses to correct the error, you must begin backup withholding on future payments and report the payments on a 1099 using the incorrect information you have. The IRS will handle any discrepancies with the contractor directly.

What to do when a contractor will not provide a W 9

Using spreadsheets to track TIN compliance

Many businesses manage their contractor information in an Excel spreadsheet or a CSV file. This works fine as long as you have a system for keeping the data current. Create columns for the contractor’s legal name, business name (if different), TIN, address, date of W-9 receipt, and backup withholding status. When you receive a W-9, update the spreadsheet immediately. When the IRS sends a mismatch notice, log the date and the action you took. This kind of data validation helps you spot patterns, such as a contractor who changes their name or TIN frequently. It also makes year-end 1099 preparation faster because you are not scrambling to find missing information.

What happens if you file a 1099 without a valid TIN

If you file a 1099 with a missing or incorrect TIN, you face penalties: $60 per return for late or incorrect information, up to a maximum per year. If the IRS determines that you intentionally ignored the requirement, the penalty rises to $310 per return with no cap. The IRS also may assess a penalty for failure to provide a correct TIN to the payee. In practice, most businesses receive a notice and have a chance to correct the error before penalties accumulate. But the easiest path is to have a valid W-9 on file for every contractor before you make the first payment.

When to seek professional help

If a contractor continues to resist despite your written requests, and you have begun backup withholding, you may want to consult a tax professional or an enrolled agent. They can help you draft a final notice, understand any state-level requirements, and ensure you are following the correct procedures. Some businesses also use a service like TaxFormHero to validate TINs and prepare 1099s electronically, which reduces the chance of data entry errors. The key is to act promptly and document everything.

Checking taxpayer identification details for ongoing compliance

Even after you have a signed W-9 on file, it is wise to re-verify the information periodically. Contractors change their business structure, move, or update their legal name. A TIN that matched last year may not match this year if the contractor incorporated or changed their EIN. Running a TIN match at the start of each year, or before you process the first payment of the year, catches these changes early. This second round of checking taxpayer identification details keeps your records clean and reduces the chance of receiving a CP2100 notice. It also shows the IRS that you are making a good faith effort to comply.

Corrections

Spot something wrong? Send it to the desk and it gets fixed in the open.